Hotels & Resorts
Listing and event details can change quickly. Please verify with the venue directly before visiting. Lavender Atlas is not responsible for third-party accuracy.
Gay-popular Fire Island Pines hotel commonly used by NYC LGBTQ+ travelers in-season.
The harbour hotel in Fire Island Pines, long known as the Botel, reopened by Tryst Hospitality in May 2026 with 30 rooms, each now with its own bathroom, a refreshed pool club, and the Blue Whale and the Pavilion on the same waterfront.
Cherry Grove hotel on the bay and home of the Ice Palace nightclub, both Fire Island staples since the mid-1950s.